Home / Candies / BUTTER TOFFEE BUTTER TOFFEE$11.95 Weight: 16 oz Plain and rum flavored available Category: Candies Description Description Our homemade butter toffee is an old fashioned Douglass treat made with fresh brown sugar! Related products ULTIMATE MALT BALLS $5.95 UNICORN POPS $2.95 WHIRLEY POP $2.95 PEANUT BRITTLE $9.95